A traditional lakeside home above a quiet cove near Vonore, with a gently sloping lawn and muted late-autumn woods across the water.

What Vonore's Home Prices Are Really Made Of

On January 6, 2026, Vonore's planning commission approved the final plat for Phase I of the Citico subdivision with a unanimous vote. The plat covers 135 lots on Highway 360 and about 44 acres zoned R-2, high density residential. The developer told the commission the homes would be one-story, three-bedroom, two-bath dwellings. The meeting minutes run a single page. They still say a lot about Vonore home prices.

Over the three months ending October 2026, the median sale price in ZIP code 37885, which covers Vonore, was $674,654, and the median home sat 113 days before selling. Sweetwater's 37874 posted a median of $330,830 and 48 days over the same window. Madisonville's 37354 posted $359,316 and 52 days. From those numbers, Vonore looks like the expensive, slow corner of Monroe County. Look at what actually sells inside 37885, though, and the ZIP turns out to hold several very different kinds of home, each priced on its own terms. A Vonore median is an average of those kinds of home, so it can't price any one of them.

Three kinds of home share one ZIP code

A median is the middle sale in a stack of sales. It tells you which homes happened to sell. It can't tell you what any one home costs. In most small towns the stack holds similar houses, so the two questions get the same answer. In 37885 the stack holds at least three very different products.

Kahite in Tellico Village. Tellico Village has eight neighborhoods. Seven are in Loudon County under ZIP 37774: Coyatee, Tommotley, Tanasi, Chota, Toqua, Chatuga and Mialaquo. The eighth, Kahite, is in Monroe County under ZIP 37885, according to the Tellico Village community site. So a Kahite sale counts in Vonore's numbers. Kahite has The Links at Kahite, an 18-hole course that opened in 2002. The POA's history records that the course and activity center were deeded to the property owners association in August 2002. The Kahite Community Center opened in August 2019. It has a fitness classroom, meeting space, tennis courts, an outdoor pool, exercise equipment, a pavilion and a playground. Kahite also has one of the Village's three marinas, which together hold 630 resident-lease boat slips.

Rarity Bay. Rarity Bay is a gated community on Tellico Lake with a Vonore address and about 900 homeowners. Its amenities include a country club, golf, tennis, pickleball, fitness facilities, a pool, community docks, horseback riding and trails.

Citico. The newest of the three is the subdivision from that January meeting. The Citico marketing site lists a starting price of $359,900 and three floor plans, each three bedrooms, two baths and 1,620 square feet. When Citico's preliminary plan came before the commission in July 2024, the HOA agreement was described as covering private streets and emergency egress plus a clubhouse, pool, pickleball court, BBQ area and central mailbox.

Inside 37885 What it is Price signal on record
Kahite, Tellico Village Golf, marina and community center neighborhood that pays a POA assessment 2026 Tellico Village assessment of $186.98 a month
Rarity Bay Gated Tellico Lake community with a country club About 900 existing homeowners
Citico New subdivision on Highway 360, 135 Phase I lots Marketed from $359,900
Everything else in Vonore Town homes and rural property Trades among the rest of the ZIP's sales

Three of the four rows are planned communities, and their buyers are paying for club and lake amenities as well as the house. When enough of those homes close in one quarter, the middle of the stack can move up, and the Vonore median then reflects the lake-and-golf product more than the town.

How the same mix can slow the pace

The same mix can also lengthen the 113-day median. A lake or golf community home near the top of the market is a narrower purchase than a three-bedroom house in town. Fewer buyers are shopping for it at any given time. When homes like that make up a large share of a ZIP's sales, they can push the ZIP's median days on market up even if ordinary homes in town sell faster.

Sales volume can move the mix as well. There were 49 homes sold in 37885 in October 2026, up from 25 in October 2025. When the number of sales nearly doubles in a year, the type of home behind that growth decides where the median lands. The 13.4% year-over-year rise in Vonore's three-month median records what sold. Some of it may come from which homes closed, so before you assume a home has gained that much, check its own comparable sales.

Tellico Plains shows how this works with an even smaller sample. Over the three months ending October 2026, the 37385 median was $451,019, up 70.2% year over year, with a median of 103 days on market. The ZIP had 20 sales in October. With that few sales, a handful of larger mountain properties can shift a median by a lot, so the 70.2% figure says more about which homes sold than about what any one Tellico Plains home is worth. If Tellico Plains is on your list, our posts on mountain views in Monroe County listings and the Cherohala's fall color down to Tellico Plains explain what drives prices on that end of the county.

What Citico could do to the Vonore number

Citico is a 135-lot first phase of one-story homes marketed from $359,900, which is within a few hundred dollars of Madisonville's three-month median of $359,316. As Citico homes close, each sale is recorded in 37885 next to the Kahite and Rarity Bay sales.

The math follows from that. Enough closings near $360,000 in one ZIP will pull its median down, and they will probably shorten its median days on market too, if those homes sell at the pace of three-bedroom houses elsewhere in the county. None of that would mean Vonore got cheaper or that the lake communities lost value. The mix would just tilt toward a different product. A buyer who sees the Vonore median fall over the next year should ask what sold before deciding the market has softened.

New subdivisions here can take longer than planned. In July 2024 the developer set a goal of finishing the subdivision by March or April 2025. The final plat for Phase I was approved in January 2026. If you're waiting on a new home anywhere in Monroe County, build some slack into your timeline.

Sweetwater and Madisonville differ from each other, too

Once you stop treating Vonore as one market, take a second look at the I-75 towns. Their medians are close, but their pricing behaves differently. Over the three months ending October 2026, Sweetwater homes sold at a median of 94.1% of list price, down 3.6 points from a year earlier. Madisonville homes sold at 99.8% of list over the same window, up 3.9 points, and their median days on market fell by 22 days.

For a buyer, that difference shows up in the offer. In Sweetwater this fall, a typical home closed about six cents per dollar below its asking price, which leaves room to negotiate. In Madisonville a typical home closed at nearly full price, and sellers there have had less reason to come down. Two towns with medians about $28,000 apart behaved like different markets at the negotiating table.

For regional context, East Tennessee REALTORS put the 2025 median sale price across the region at $374,500 and forecast 3.1% home-price growth for 2026 in its 2026 forecast report. Monroe County as a whole posted a $378,726 median over the three months ending October 2026, close to that regional figure. The county number is an average of Sweetwater's discounts, Madisonville's near-full-price sales and Vonore's lake-community sales into one figure.

Comparing towns by the house you'd actually buy

The useful comparison starts with the house you plan to buy. A buyer who wants a one-story three-bedroom near town should look at Citico's marketed pricing and at recent three-bedroom sales in Madisonville and Sweetwater, and ignore the Vonore median. A buyer who wants golf, a marina slip and a community center should compare Kahite with the Loudon County neighborhoods of Tellico Village and with Rarity Bay. Our earlier post on living near Tellico Lake in Loudon County covers the other side of that county line. If this is a second home, our post on vacation homes in Monroe County adds that angle.

Ongoing costs matter too. The Tellico Village POA's 2026 budget presentation, dated November 13, 2025, sets the assessment at $186.98 a month, or $2,243.76 a year. That figure comes from the POA's published budget and may not be every cost of owning there. This is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm the numbers for your own situation with the right professional.

A few questions buyers ask about Vonore

Is Kahite part of Tellico Village? Yes. Kahite is one of Tellico Village's eight neighborhoods and the only one in Monroe County. Its sales count in Vonore's ZIP code data. The other seven neighborhoods count in Loudon County's 37774.

Is Tellico Village still building? The Tellico Village POA's second-quarter 2026 newsletter estimates 123 new homes across the Village in calendar 2026 and reports 69 home approvals in the second quarter. Those figures cover the whole Village. The newsletter doesn't break them out for Kahite.

Is Vonore more expensive than Madisonville? It depends on which part of Vonore you mean. A planned lake or golf community home and a new three-bedroom on Highway 360 are different purchases. Price each one against comparable homes rather than against a ZIP code median.

If you're comparing Vonore, Madisonville and Sweetwater, I can pull the recent sales that match the home you want, so you're comparing similar houses and not ZIP code medians. Call me anytime, or if you already own in Monroe County, Request Your Free Home Valuation and get a number based on homes like yours. With Robin L Skeen, we'll handle the details so you don't have to.

Work With Robin

Buying and selling real estate can be a stressful life event. Let 30 years of experience work for you! Robin can assist you in working toward a successful transaction.